Miss Jetster Jay
PUZZLE: This was such a well put together funny story with really cute art and far out please teach me your ways with doing lineless art that looks so nice so quickly. With that said, I think that you could have used more contrast or simpler artwork in some of the smaller panels because there is a slight loss of clarity when we're in that close. The placement of speech bubbles also doesn't quite follow the left/right top/bottom - even on the first page, it starts off really well but we're forced to jump up from the bottom of the page to the top of the last panel.
Quote
Ahhh thank you!. Yeah, a few other people have mentioned it (including a not void person who I showed them too earlier) but I've always had a huge problem with contrast and keeping my value range large. The problem just becomes so much worse when I don't have outlines to help. I'm gonna try to push it harder next round, even if some dumb part of me think it looks weird.
The speech bubbles also suck yeah, they ended up having odd placement because I was just desperately trying to fit everything on without cutting even more text.
GOD DAMN IT ROFLQU: Take the critique with a grain of salt. After all, this was done in 4 days, so before everything else, you guys did terrific.
Quote
Ah jeez, thank you so much! I'll probably make the pages larger next round. I wanted to try and do smaller, simpler comics, but I really really struggled getting all the story on the page. I ended up making F's speech so long-winded and overly proper, and combined with the fact I was having difficulty feeling like the "WHO DUN IT?!" page wouldn't be funny without alot of not-characters, I was just jamming stuff in there. When I finished bubbling the 2nd page I just stared at it knowing it was really bad but not knowing anyway to fix it at that point.
Yeah, I didn't really like the speech bubbles either. I really wanna learn how to hand letter, but I'm not sure I have to time to learn it in the middle of this tourney. I think I might try a light coloured grey for the next round, a little more organic and hand drawn, with maybe a tiny drop shadow or scrabbly outline to keep it separate.
PyrasTerran:
Puzzlething: I love the conclusion to this comic! but I felt like it was a little wordy and I got a little confused with page 2 cause I felt like the "you call could be suspects" line would have been better suited further down, like I know it works where it is too but it gave me pause nonetheless.
Quote
Yeah, bubble placement most def got weird on page 2. I planned stuff out, but it just got away from me :c
Field Marshal Lionel Forsythe W. Underwood XIII, GBE:
Puzzlething, you know how to pique my interest with the road less taken as shown by what you've done here. I only have one thing to say: We at the Hercule Poirot Club adore this to pieces.
Quote
Underwood♥♥♥
Charlie:
PUZZLE - I feel like your art was very charming but your entry was definitely carried by the funny story. Don't get me wrong I loved the art in this but I didn't get very much visual information as to where they really were or some panels felt hard to read due to lack of contrast. Even then I still thought it was visually pleasant and the punchline was just fantastic - very nice work.
Quote
No I totally understand! I'm trying to do a thing I'm not very good at, so the art is def gonna be weird. I'm like totally relying on my story to not just die immediately (though I think I'm p much doomed in the 2nd round now)
ablob:
Puzzlething - This comic is hilarious. That is all.
Quote
Ahhhh thanks! It's nice to know that staring at a screen for 8 hours mumbling "i don't even know what funny is anymore" totally works
Kozispoon:
PUZZLETHING- I ha no idea where this was going, but when it got there, I loved it. This punchline/payoff was hilarious! You build up this super serious windy twisty whodunit and in the end I feel stayed true to your opponent. Not to mention added your own brand of silliness (honestly, who beats someone with a puppy??)
Quote
Ahhh thanks! Hopefully it didn't come off as forcefully monkey-cheese random, I just wanted to do all dog-themed murders the dog show founder.
otakutaylor: Light Speed Critique: Puzzle, the different colored panels did a great job of separate each accusation, but I didn't realize F's face was in the lower right due to the shading from the coat. Nice idea, with the blending coat, but the transition started too high up I think.
Quote
Ah it was just supposed to be a lit section, not exactly a line of transition. it's supposed to be kind vague when a where it starts since I made F more like a silhouette than a solid person, but I think it just ended up being too confusing.
Artist
[Or enter a bunch of characters till I get an action hero replacement :3c]