I thought it was as good as a Watchmen movie could possibly be. Any closer to the source material would have wrecked it and made it as heavy and overworked as the book was. The watch thing made sense because it made it seem like it was the watch his father had him work on, the Squid being removed was A-OK, since they handled it in a way that wouldn't require another 30 minutes of explanation and cut a lot of the lesser stuff (and if you look it said S.Q.U.I.D. under the launch screens, sweet!). Hell, I was even okay with the Hollis thing getting cut, since it wasn't 100% essential to the plot and you could guess Hollis ended up dead anyway when New York got vaporized. I think the music was perfect. The Flight of the Valkyries thing WAS goofy and it was harking back to previously filmed Vietnam scenes. Essentially Snyder was saying "hey imagine if in Apocalypse Now, it wasn't helicopters, just a GIANT BLUE GUY", which IS ridiculous and funny. The same for the sex-scene, it was sweet and all but really really funny. Wasn't almost all the music mentioned in the book? I know Times They Are A-Changin' and All Along The Watchtower were.
Overall though I really really enjoyed it and thought they left just enough out for the movie and book to coexist happily.
99 Problems and a Cat
Croi Desai vs. HR99
@ 12:30 AM Apr 23rd