Daku vs. Knifes
Critiques & Comments
# 33
and Daku, by rule your borders I mean-Define them against the line art inside them-Dont let the pencil lines break the borders unless your characters or other elements of the art is breaking the panel for a reason.Inking your pencils and spoting your solis blacks would go a long way to improving your story telling.
# 32
I agree-I liked your pacing alot- It has a great deal of energy- and your panel layouts were clean and dynamic. Knifes is a cool character and carries all the good qualiteis of manga. I look fo=ward to seeing your next battle.
Daku-showing alot of impovement-although you still refuse to rule your borders-that would help the quality of your work alot-Keep pluggin away dude-I admire your effort!
Daku-showing alot of impovement-although you still refuse to rule your borders-that would help the quality of your work alot-Keep pluggin away dude-I admire your effort!
# 31
Daku, i love the design as always. And it's getting clear you really like to blast your way through. Maybe more pages would've worked better, but you might've not had the time or something, keep it up.
Knifes, great dynamics. Sometimes the panels are kinda dazzling or crowded with so many lines i have to stare at it to tell what's happening, Advantage of staring is looking better at the image. I dig the character. Dying to see the next fight.
Voted!
Knifes, great dynamics. Sometimes the panels are kinda dazzling or crowded with so many lines i have to stare at it to tell what's happening, Advantage of staring is looking better at the image. I dig the character. Dying to see the next fight.
Voted!
# 30
lol I'm not... actually I killed off two of my pens while inking this XD thanks!
# 29
nice fight
trp: you have good action lines (you must be a patient person.. I'm too lazy to do a proper one.. haha)
kain: sometimes it kinda hard to see what happened, but it's ok. well, just try to keep other chara in chara. But I like the bits that Daku actually have personality.. hahaha.
trp: you have good action lines (you must be a patient person.. I'm too lazy to do a proper one.. haha)
kain: sometimes it kinda hard to see what happened, but it's ok. well, just try to keep other chara in chara. But I like the bits that Daku actually have personality.. hahaha.
# 28
...that....was....INTENSE....o_o
*waves pom-poms* WHOOT~!
*waves pom-poms* WHOOT~!
# 27
daku, great stuff, everyone said what neededto be said, keep on bangin man
trp, you really have a good grasp of paneling and angles. simple and uncluttered, everything looks neat and easy on the eye. the last few pages were intense too. great job. if u were to improve anything, it would have to be in the story department, though i myself am totally content with ur story here. if u wanna up your stuff even more, try different settings, more unique background, doesnt have to be detailed to death, just somethign different. but for now, ur boss
trp, you really have a good grasp of paneling and angles. simple and uncluttered, everything looks neat and easy on the eye. the last few pages were intense too. great job. if u were to improve anything, it would have to be in the story department, though i myself am totally content with ur story here. if u wanna up your stuff even more, try different settings, more unique background, doesnt have to be detailed to death, just somethign different. but for now, ur boss
# 26
Man, all I gotta say is KICK. ASS. Knifes was perhaps one of the most proffesional fights I've ever seen here, and Daku has finally put forward a comic that looked a bit different. A lot has already been said, so all I offer is kudos to you both!!
# 25
Well, if your Creative score is below 7.5, then somebody obviously put there expectations too high!
Kainsword: Line art is looking better, but I'm still seeing the same things as I've normaly seen in your last battles, character has a daku style to them. And you should consider using a ruler and pencil on the backgrounds before you ink them. Still, looking alot better than normal.
TRP86: I'm gonna tear into ya like a wolf on a steak!!! No seriously, art is supurb by void standards, I couldn't find anything worth picking apart (and the things that I picked previously was changed! You've got instant respect from me 10x baby!!). Um... lets see... if anything, I think that maybe there should of been an explanation as to why Daku challanged Knifes in your battle, maybe an extra page showing that somebody offered her something to fight him. But that's my suggestion. Other than that, you've got nothing to worry about really, you've been on deviantart for quite some time, and those guys rarely say anything worth while (unless it's something biased or not helpful in the least bit).
But, my suggestion is having an extra page to explain a few things here and there, but you did great! I'm kinda nervous to fight you right now... but then again, I'm currently fighting seel. Well anywho, I think that this one goes to Knifes for me. And I'm impressed that Kainsword is still willing to fight after all this time! HE'S INSANE I TELLS YA!! Keep it up or something?
Kainsword: Line art is looking better, but I'm still seeing the same things as I've normaly seen in your last battles, character has a daku style to them. And you should consider using a ruler and pencil on the backgrounds before you ink them. Still, looking alot better than normal.
TRP86: I'm gonna tear into ya like a wolf on a steak!!! No seriously, art is supurb by void standards, I couldn't find anything worth picking apart (and the things that I picked previously was changed! You've got instant respect from me 10x baby!!). Um... lets see... if anything, I think that maybe there should of been an explanation as to why Daku challanged Knifes in your battle, maybe an extra page showing that somebody offered her something to fight him. But that's my suggestion. Other than that, you've got nothing to worry about really, you've been on deviantart for quite some time, and those guys rarely say anything worth while (unless it's something biased or not helpful in the least bit).
But, my suggestion is having an extra page to explain a few things here and there, but you did great! I'm kinda nervous to fight you right now... but then again, I'm currently fighting seel. Well anywho, I think that this one goes to Knifes for me. And I'm impressed that Kainsword is still willing to fight after all this time! HE'S INSANE I TELLS YA!! Keep it up or something?
# 24
^^; Yeah I'm aware that my plotline isn't very creative *sweatdrops*
Would really like to get good, harsh critiques on my part for this though. I want to know where my mistakes lie and in what way I can improve them. thanks.
And umm... yeah... Kainsword I have no idea why the hell Knifes would be wielding a laser cannon. ^^;
Would really like to get good, harsh critiques on my part for this though. I want to know where my mistakes lie and in what way I can improve them. thanks.
And umm... yeah... Kainsword I have no idea why the hell Knifes would be wielding a laser cannon. ^^;
# 23
Holy shit!
Okay, Daku. Great improvement. You can actually follow whats going on this time without straining your brain. No offense ^^; *claps*
TRP86. Ooohhhhhhgah! Fuggin amazing job. I love the movement and the inking and everything. Awesom job!
Okay, Daku. Great improvement. You can actually follow whats going on this time without straining your brain. No offense ^^; *claps*
TRP86. Ooohhhhhhgah! Fuggin amazing job. I love the movement and the inking and everything. Awesom job!
# 22
very great stuff.. the Knives fight is superb! professional looking sheit!!
# 21
Ok! Official commentage!
I just HAVE to ask: Kainsword... what's up with knifes firing a laser cannon at the opening?? I mean i know we haven't seen this char in action before.. but for goodness sakes her name is KNIFES.. and reading her profile she does not seem the laser cannon type. Nice straightforward fight.. nothing spectacular but not bad either.
TRP! I like your art muchly... that's one of the best renditions of Daku i've seen in...ever. 9 pages... damn.The fight was well thought out and merited those pages though. Nice dialogue (though i can't even count how many times i've heard "no one has ever dodged that combination before") and fight sequences. Keep it up!
Knifes gets the higher vote from me.. but you both did a really good job.
I just HAVE to ask: Kainsword... what's up with knifes firing a laser cannon at the opening?? I mean i know we haven't seen this char in action before.. but for goodness sakes her name is KNIFES.. and reading her profile she does not seem the laser cannon type. Nice straightforward fight.. nothing spectacular but not bad either.
TRP! I like your art muchly... that's one of the best renditions of Daku i've seen in...ever. 9 pages... damn.The fight was well thought out and merited those pages though. Nice dialogue (though i can't even count how many times i've heard "no one has ever dodged that combination before") and fight sequences. Keep it up!
Knifes gets the higher vote from me.. but you both did a really good job.
# 20
Hehe, I'd thought you would have uploaded way before I did, Daku XD Can't wait for this fight to start.
# 19
I had finally uploaded, and I really tried my hardest to get the opponent right this time^_^
# 18
trp86: log into the forum and message toast would be the easiest I think.
I'll be looking forward to your fight. 9 pages was it? sweet~
I'll be looking forward to your fight. 9 pages was it? sweet~
# 17
Patience XD;; You've already waited for over 20 days lol.
I just hope this thing doesn't screw up on me... where the heck can I check to see where my images are on the server?
I just hope this thing doesn't screw up on me... where the heck can I check to see where my images are on the server?
# 16
Five more days is too long! I NEED to see this fight!
Both of you guys better rock out on this one.. don't disappoint me!!
Both of you guys better rock out on this one.. don't disappoint me!!
# 15
Not as far as I know. ._.; I bet they are...mebbe you should consult the forum.
# 14
Uploaded... is there anyway to check if all our stuff is up here? I had to upload my images one by one because my computer hanged everytime I tried sending all 9 pages at one shot =_=;
# 13
I can't wait to see it all!
# 12
Urgh, I finally finished drawing all the pages... =_= Gonna add the text and sound effects and upload it via the school computer tomorrow. Ganbari masu!
# 11
Kain, win or loss, i admire your fukking willpower.
Welcome to the new guy.
Good luck, now go kick ass.
Welcome to the new guy.
Good luck, now go kick ass.
# 10
e.e Me sucks lots at drawing mecha and digimon and stuff... I can only hope I did Daku justice T_T
# 9
hehe, i can't wait to see how you draw daku. X3 no offense to anyone, but there haven't really been many people who can draw him well. THIS FIGHT'LL ROCK ASS
# 8
Damn right Knifes is hot! Marry me? (j/k)
Anywho, good luck to the both of you!
Anywho, good luck to the both of you!
# 7
Good luck to both of ya! *claps*
# 6
Trp86, BRING IT ON!!!
# 5
Ehehe... *grins and rubs back of neck* domou, arigato gozaimasu... I'm doing my best for this one, I hope you guys will like it ^__^
# 4
You betta win TRP! Or I'll bash your head in! Or something.
# 3
Knifes! Knifes! She's our gal, if she can't do it...well...the other guy can!
RAH! *strikepose*
RAH! *strikepose*
# 2
seems like an interesting match up
cant to wait to see what the new guy can bring
and how far kainsword improved
cant to wait to see what the new guy can bring
and how far kainsword improved
# 1
knifes is HOT!!
Regular Match
Drawing Time:
4 weeks
Ended:
Jan 9th, 2005
Votes Cast:
29
Page Views:
1496
Winner:
PTPS
99 Problems and a Cat
Croi Desai vs. HR99
@ 12:30 AM Apr 23rd
einsam
Colbitzer
@ 3:32 PM Apr 17th
Birthright
Saal, Louise Ambre-Aliona, and Llaana
@ 3:44 PM Apr 16th
Help Needed
Theakon
@ 2:19 PM Apr 16th
The Great Switcheroo
Louise Ambre-Aliona vs. Luniel Gekka
@ 3:26 AM Apr 15th
| ||
| ||
| ||
| ||
|
268 Guests, 1 User
Most Online Today: 290.
Most Online Ever: 1,184 (Jan 13, 2020, 06:21 PM)
Artist
trp: High-quality, dynamic work on all fronts. I'm impressed!