Two entries with very different moods and art styles. Fun to read.
Quality was surprisingly hard for me to figure out. Cyrine's style fits the silliness of the comic and it's pretty amusing to see what faces Ms. Moppit makes. However, there's a lot of blank space. It works in some places and in others, makes it feel like you just didn't feel like coloring.
Madison did winning out in quality. I have to admit I'm partial to the coloring style.There was also a more complete feeling to the panels. I am going to say that after looking at your panels again, they were somewhat boring. This may be a minor complaint because the story you were trying to tell was to build tension of some sort. And the fact that the story seemed so short (to me) it effected the art.
And that leads to Creativity, which I gave to cyrine. While both stories (plots...whatever) were different genres, cyrine's felt more complete. Madison's, while having the potential to be interesting, ends abruptly. I'm not saying every entry has to be 8+ pages but I feel like it just ended without any prompting.
Entertainment-wise, cyrine won again because of general silliness and being complete. Plus, as I said before, I enjoy Ms. Moppit's expressions. Madison's almost had me but kinda left me wishing there was more to it.
I love the amazing painting style we got on our VCPD side...as far as the puppet side though I love the amount of emotional faces. The whole blonde brunette redhead thing kinda killed ya moppit...although I love the comedy. Jacie had great shades...I wish there had been at least one more page.
While I like the thriller feel in Jacie's side of the battle, it just seemed unfinished. I felt Ms. Moppit side had a more complete story. So while I give Madison a win in Quality, I must give Cyrine victory in both Creativity and Entertainment.
Just to let you know cyrine...your character has been added to my hitlist...mwahahaha, when I finally get the balls to ink and color my character onto there...your gonna be one I'm gonna hit up!!!!! Oh and once more...I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE her face on page five, frame 3....D:>
Hmm I can see the light blonde and skin tones in my comic only when I look at the computer screen at a side angle, but not when I look at it directly O_O weird.
Comments (18)