Um. Ok. Here goes ...
Kura x: I think your character is ok. I read some of your past fights and they are ok too. What I don't like is when creators have the story in their fights crossover to the next one ... It's really annoying and I think very few can actually pull it off. Mamoru is the exception, but barely. I got lost in your story. Also, all your characters look the same. Try to vary them a little. At least give us something to differenciate them from one another.
Stilled_life: At first I thought your art was exciting and fresh until I got to page 2, last panel. Yikes! What happened to those fingers!!! Also, readability a big issue here in your comic. Some parts I couldn't figure out how to read. Also, changing font and font sizes too often was aproblem for me. A Big annoyance actually. Pulled me out of the story.
Yay! The last pages work!
Kura - I didn't like the fact that Kyra played such a small part in this piece, especially since it was supposed to be her battle. The comic itself was okay, the humor was there, but nothing side-splitting. The art was decent, not your best, not your worst. I suspect that's from BR, no? The last panel on the last page really bugs me, the pose looks very weird for Veronica, and Mize's left leg has some bendy action. On a whole, I'd say the comic was mediocre.
Stilled_life - Nice battle, but I think it could have been more consistent. The places that you used hatching and cross-hatching looked REALLY good, especially Veronica's appearance on the second page. I must admit, the ending was a little bit confusing until I figured it out, in which case I thought it was a little funny and creepy at the same time. The only problem I saw art-wise was Veronica's hand on the last panel of page three. Her fingers look bent back too far, and it was a little distracting. Your story was a bit too vague for my tastes as well.
This was darn hard to vote on, but I gave my votes to Kura by a smidge. I think both of you could pull off some absolutely awesome comics, we all just need more practice.
Oh crippy christ! My computer crashed last night just after I posted!! I lucked out! Can't wait to see your stuff Kura. Votes people, and give us some feed back, we put off homework for this! Be generous.
Comments (21)