Kimitoku vs. Mr. Impossible
Critiques & Comments
# 63
I'm sure you got the point with all the crits, so I won't get into that in this fight. All I have to say is, Take it in. You're in void, no matter what you will get crits. Mr.Impossible, your fight seems a bit lazy after seeing this over your last, but it's still good. Very nice job, both of you. Good luck.
# 62
Alright people, i voted! I know im a tad bit late, but its all good! I split it up pretty evenly i think and i gave the right choice. I like Mr.Is comic the best out of both of them. I liked your stuff Smiley no lie, and uve already gotten grief over critiques and all and everyone already said basically everything i was thinking so im not even gonna go there. Mr. I, i think you were holding off a tad, but i understand, i think what happened. You did the 3 pages, and then sent it in immediatly. Then smiley got the entension so there would be no way to do an extra page or two. I understand whatever happened because of the circumstances. much love to you both. Nice battle!
# 61
True, but making excuses to cover your flaws is equally as vain. It's like you're expecting us to go "OH, now that you put it THAT way, your entry is PERFECTLY fine !"....which we won't.
# 60
I don't have a big ego. There is nothing wrong with responding back to the critiques that are given.
# 59
I've got a critique myself.
Smiley: First thing's first... don't be an 0r0ch1, he had a huge ego and expected everybody on void to bow down and kiss his ass and praise everything he did. Guess where he is now Not at void that's for sure. Everybody else pretty much nailed what you needed to improve upon (Though I can't understand why you're not listning), and Zato pretty much said what I wanted to say about the story. Basicly, I think you need to swallow your pride, and maybe think to yourself that maybe the critiques you're getting are there to help and not the oppasite. So I'll just leave it at that.
Impossible: Dry humor man... lazyness tends to get to the best of us at times, but I know you can bring it to the table if you just GET OFF YO ASS BOY!! lol. Seriously, you're ripping us off here man.
Both are good comics, but remember this is VOID! Not Deviantart! Keep it up or something?
Smiley: First thing's first... don't be an 0r0ch1, he had a huge ego and expected everybody on void to bow down and kiss his ass and praise everything he did. Guess where he is now Not at void that's for sure. Everybody else pretty much nailed what you needed to improve upon (Though I can't understand why you're not listning), and Zato pretty much said what I wanted to say about the story. Basicly, I think you need to swallow your pride, and maybe think to yourself that maybe the critiques you're getting are there to help and not the oppasite. So I'll just leave it at that.
Impossible: Dry humor man... lazyness tends to get to the best of us at times, but I know you can bring it to the table if you just GET OFF YO ASS BOY!! lol. Seriously, you're ripping us off here man.
Both are good comics, but remember this is VOID! Not Deviantart! Keep it up or something?
# 58
Wow, your argument proved EXACTLY what I'm trying to tell you. You can't just settle for typical ninja tricks with a character like this, you have to WOW us. Having only 3-4 pages to work with is no excuse. You should have been able to do something impressive given that minimum, but instead you settled for the typical ninja fight.
Oh, and learn how to draw a katana blade correctly; that's a weakness that'll get you in trouble with about half the fighters here.
Oh, and learn how to draw a katana blade correctly; that's a weakness that'll get you in trouble with about half the fighters here.
# 57
isnt this like the 8th phone
# 56
isnt this like the 8th phone
# 55
Mr. Impossible vs. P2? wow that woud be epic. no humor just a slug fest... i can only dream for now. maybe after i cool my jets a while. oh and C2j holla at me at home or hit me at the e-mail. if you dont got it. get it from sauceboy (i broke my phone) te-he
# 54
excccuuuuuuuuuuuuuuses!
seriously! stop it! nothing makes you look worse than defending your art with an unnecessary EGO. youre garnering noones respect around here
seriously! stop it! nothing makes you look worse than defending your art with an unnecessary EGO. youre garnering noones respect around here
# 53
Zato I really don't know what you mean about losing your respect.
Back to the subject at hand...
If you look in my bio it saids that Kimitoku has ninja fighting skills. So that is what I put in the fight. If the fight was more than three or four pages, Kimitoku would be doing more than just a ninja teleport and sword attack.
Back to the subject at hand...
If you look in my bio it saids that Kimitoku has ninja fighting skills. So that is what I put in the fight. If the fight was more than three or four pages, Kimitoku would be doing more than just a ninja teleport and sword attack.
# 52
yeah possible we feel u on the laziness thing(which has plagued me since i been here).You just got a crowd of people waiting for the true you to hop out, i kno if we ever fight(hint) i want your fullest(which i expect from all the alliance)since the griffin beat down made me touch up on a few things,i owe some serious payback....so i'm dropping hint now after i fight everyone else in alliance i'm going after griffin for a rematch
respark over and out
respark over and out
# 51
Gross! Wahahaha! Covered in snot.. thats something I've never seen before o_o;;
# 50
impossible I heard what happened at the con. Give me a call when you get a chance I told you your talent wasnt going to go unnoticed (well atleast I thought i did).
# 49
wow... u guys are pretty heated here! i happy you all thought this battle was worth lookin at. way to go smiley... keep on keepin on and i'll do the same. and don't worry void heads my next battle will include backgrounds and a crazy twist for the traveler (i'm surprised noone has done anything to crazy with that guy yet). and it is really to bad none of you guys were at the baltimore comicon cuz you all may have been shocked. any how i luvs ya all.oh and as far as me turning in a crapy comic... THATS IMPOSSIBLE! (but laziness can creep out every once and again.) lol.
# 48
smiley: Your art is great! for real.. don't worry about the critiques . just use them and show them what you can do. I HAVE been criticied.. for my english and my anatomy and by my unclean art. i just tryng to correct those critiques in every fight. Mr impossible have a lot talent and i always said i like that character. don't get mad if you lose. give him credit. SMILE!!!
# 47
Ugh, you just lost respect points from me, Smiley. I thought you were above all that. But let's not sidetrack, time for some crits.
Kimi : Shorty and everyone else trying to get the point across already said enough about the art aspect, so I'll crack down on some other stuff. As your first entry, you present a solid fight with good colors and some nice direction. BUT, the fight was nothing surprising at all. Just the normal "ninja teleport", "sensei-training flashback" and "secret ninja technique isn't really more than a normal slash with a background and subtext". In other words, it's just like watching Kimi and Mr. Imp play out a VERY typical ninja-fight. Try to be more original and perhaps I'll be impressed, I was looking more forward to seeing what a catgirl-ninja coulda dished, but I'm pretty disappointed. I'm looking forward to seeing improvements on this, I'm sure they'll be great.
Mr. Imp : Yeah I agree you were holding back on this one. The lack of backgrounds takes away from the art, but the lines and the hatching kinda make up for it. You also presented a more entertaining story than Kimi, so I'll give you the points for that as well. Everyone kinda mentioned everything else, so I'll leave you with what I got. Keep it up.
Kimi : Shorty and everyone else trying to get the point across already said enough about the art aspect, so I'll crack down on some other stuff. As your first entry, you present a solid fight with good colors and some nice direction. BUT, the fight was nothing surprising at all. Just the normal "ninja teleport", "sensei-training flashback" and "secret ninja technique isn't really more than a normal slash with a background and subtext". In other words, it's just like watching Kimi and Mr. Imp play out a VERY typical ninja-fight. Try to be more original and perhaps I'll be impressed, I was looking more forward to seeing what a catgirl-ninja coulda dished, but I'm pretty disappointed. I'm looking forward to seeing improvements on this, I'm sure they'll be great.
Mr. Imp : Yeah I agree you were holding back on this one. The lack of backgrounds takes away from the art, but the lines and the hatching kinda make up for it. You also presented a more entertaining story than Kimi, so I'll give you the points for that as well. Everyone kinda mentioned everything else, so I'll leave you with what I got. Keep it up.
# 46
Even though Mr. Impossible is holding back it looks like he is going to win.
# 45
I hope you guys aren't in the opinion that we know "nothing" about comics. Like I said before Smiley, you can ignore what I say you need to work on, but that doesn't mean I'm wrong. Your work doesn't need to be a Da Vinci, but it does need to be presentable in order to make it to the next level.
Nobody said that any of us underestimated Mr. Impossible either, but this was a slack job and he knows it. No biggie. Sure it'll be great next time around like his previous battle
Nobody said that any of us underestimated Mr. Impossible either, but this was a slack job and he knows it. No biggie. Sure it'll be great next time around like his previous battle
# 44
nice fights from both of you guys. I have no critiques (hope I spelled it right) or anything, im just gonna say impossible is SUPER holding back. but I understand you not devoting your life to a 3 page fight I know how much you gotta work all the time cause we are all there with you accept 4 when u go on break and spend like 5 hours ( sike nah). But again nice fight
# 43
"try holding a stick or a sword or whatever like that and you'll see that you have NO control over the sword, specially the way you got that wrist angled.. that shit just HURTS. Not to mention the wonky shit that mr.impossible doing, nigga look like he breakin n shit"
If your talking about how Kimitoku is holding the sword in the first page there is nothing wrong with it. But on the second page I see what you mean. Also I drew Mr. Impossible posed like that to show that he is shocked. I'm not trying to draw life-like pictures. Because in real life there are no Catgirls or a kid called Mr. Impossible who has hands that are bigger than his head. Its a comic not a Leonardo De Venci painting.
If your talking about how Kimitoku is holding the sword in the first page there is nothing wrong with it. But on the second page I see what you mean. Also I drew Mr. Impossible posed like that to show that he is shocked. I'm not trying to draw life-like pictures. Because in real life there are no Catgirls or a kid called Mr. Impossible who has hands that are bigger than his head. Its a comic not a Leonardo De Venci painting.
# 42
From now on if I have a problem with the way someone addresses my art work I'll email them -_-.
# 41
first of all why is it that when I was ONLY talking to shortfury two other people jump in and start being defensive?
# 40
mr impossible....if they only knew....big time baby!!!!!
# 39
Kimitoku's tail hanging out like that looks like a pink sock to me(for those who know what that is)but yeah i think u did give this the more did possible did,and i like the style of coloring u did for this,i agree with the anatomy its looks off here and there but i think for only being yo"second"comic ever u did pretty good.
Impossible why for the life of me do i feel your holding back,i think u have something dope to show but just ain't doing it, i mean this was coo but your on my list of people i know can do better
Impossible why for the life of me do i feel your holding back,i think u have something dope to show but just ain't doing it, i mean this was coo but your on my list of people i know can do better
# 38
anatomy ISNT wonky? dude LOOK AT IT! i didnt realise that you are the ANATOMY GURU OF COMICDOM. you need to stop making excuses and PERSONAL ATTACKS at the people who are critting you and grow up.
if you cant even take a MARLEYCRIT then you have zero hope in comics
...and since when did void become so sensitive about crits? christ on cupcakes people, youre not pros. your shit isnt INDESTRUCTABLE
you newbies make me mad sometimes
if you cant even take a MARLEYCRIT then you have zero hope in comics
...and since when did void become so sensitive about crits? christ on cupcakes people, youre not pros. your shit isnt INDESTRUCTABLE
you newbies make me mad sometimes
# 37
sounds like somebody cant talk critques.
she does have a point though man, on page 2 the way she holding that sword is NASTY. try holding a stick or a sword or whatever like that and you'll see that you have NO control over the sword, specially the way you got that wrist angled.. that shit just HURTS. Not to mention the wonky shit that mr.impossible doing, nigga look like he breakin n shit
the spider pose though... its aight... the beef i have with that pose is that the shoulder on the right should be shifted down more, and of course the shoulder on the left should be up more...if you really size them arms up, they would prolly hit her knees... and i dont know much bout yer chracter .. but normal humans dont have arms that reach down to their KNEES.
we tell you these things becuase sometimes ya'll dont SEE THEM.
dont take as we're pretending to be BETTER than you ... cuase shit i know i'm not ... its just OUR view on YOUR work.
thus the term CRITIQUE.
she does have a point though man, on page 2 the way she holding that sword is NASTY. try holding a stick or a sword or whatever like that and you'll see that you have NO control over the sword, specially the way you got that wrist angled.. that shit just HURTS. Not to mention the wonky shit that mr.impossible doing, nigga look like he breakin n shit
the spider pose though... its aight... the beef i have with that pose is that the shoulder on the right should be shifted down more, and of course the shoulder on the left should be up more...if you really size them arms up, they would prolly hit her knees... and i dont know much bout yer chracter .. but normal humans dont have arms that reach down to their KNEES.
we tell you these things becuase sometimes ya'll dont SEE THEM.
dont take as we're pretending to be BETTER than you ... cuase shit i know i'm not ... its just OUR view on YOUR work.
thus the term CRITIQUE.
# 36
being aggressive? I'm being honest with you. I may have given you a little too much credit though.
If you don't want to take my comments into consideration thats fine. That doesn't mean my comments aren't right. She is spiderlike... her arms are as long as her legs. You did the same thing to Mr. Impossible on the first page. Bottom right. Get it right. Her hand has no knuckles in your second page. Mr. Impossible has no shoulder blades in your top left panel etc. etc. Learn how to take a crit before getting defensive. I'm trying to help.
btw. I'm working on two other projects besides void, and I'm creating a new character for void. If you're knocking my productivity why don't you take a look in the forums.
If you don't want to take my comments into consideration thats fine. That doesn't mean my comments aren't right. She is spiderlike... her arms are as long as her legs. You did the same thing to Mr. Impossible on the first page. Bottom right. Get it right. Her hand has no knuckles in your second page. Mr. Impossible has no shoulder blades in your top left panel etc. etc. Learn how to take a crit before getting defensive. I'm trying to help.
btw. I'm working on two other projects besides void, and I'm creating a new character for void. If you're knocking my productivity why don't you take a look in the forums.
# 35
oh and btw you should study drawing hand too shorty.
# 34
Shortfury: "some of the anatomy was a little wonky (the crouched stance was almost spiderlike) but otherwise a good effort"
Um Shortfury you need to lighten up a bit when you comment. You always come out aggressive. This is my second comic ever! To be honest I'm just happy I sent something in. Also my anatony is not wonky. The crouching pose is not spider-like. Its just a crouch pose of a cat-like-woman preparing to fight. Btw, when will you sumit a fight? Also Mr. Impossible doesn't create wonkey anatony for he is the king of comics!
(please don't take this comment personal ^_^;)
Um Shortfury you need to lighten up a bit when you comment. You always come out aggressive. This is my second comic ever! To be honest I'm just happy I sent something in. Also my anatony is not wonky. The crouching pose is not spider-like. Its just a crouch pose of a cat-like-woman preparing to fight. Btw, when will you sumit a fight? Also Mr. Impossible doesn't create wonkey anatony for he is the king of comics!
(please don't take this comment personal ^_^;)
# 33
ouch... dont worry, its only my pride. its cool i respect all you guys opinions plus u are one of my favorites, spikes. all you void types are tough to please.
# 32
ooops.... that last comment was actually made by shortfury =/ I keep logging in as james
# 31
Good first entry from smiley. Nicely colored, and good job establishing your character. There were technical issues here and there... some of the anatomy was a little wonky (the crouched stance was almost spiderlike) but otherwise a good effort
Mr. Impossible's entry was good too, but it was much more lazy... comical but lazy. No colors and the line weights were all over the place. You could have at least added some tones, considering you had an extra week to work on it. Seems you did a little bit of underestimating.
Both of you really need to work on developing backgrounds. Study your anatomy too (especially hands)
Kimitoku should have this one. She put much more effort in and it shows.
Mr. Impossible's entry was good too, but it was much more lazy... comical but lazy. No colors and the line weights were all over the place. You could have at least added some tones, considering you had an extra week to work on it. Seems you did a little bit of underestimating.
Both of you really need to work on developing backgrounds. Study your anatomy too (especially hands)
Kimitoku should have this one. She put much more effort in and it shows.
# 30
thanks for the feed back all. but i didnt know that i had to submit more when there is an extension. is that the rule? anyhow i really only had time to post the schedualed 3 pages i still have 2 other fights going up soon and with all the work in my real life i dont have time for more
# 29
well smiley it's good to see you finished and turned in your battle on time but over all great work.i was very surprised you even put my character in the battle . Mr. Impossible the end had me dying lughing, that's why you are my hero.
# 28
use mr. impossible as test for new alliance members? funny idea xD
both guys did great anyway, looks like you both did the others character justice too.
both guys did great anyway, looks like you both did the others character justice too.
# 27
The Impossible Sneeze Attack!!! AHHHHH-CHOO.
This fight was personal preference for me. Impossible, your lineart is the cool beans, but I almost always choose fighting over comedy.
Smiley, you has'a neat style going, your colors are trippy.
This fight was personal preference for me. Impossible, your lineart is the cool beans, but I almost always choose fighting over comedy.
Smiley, you has'a neat style going, your colors are trippy.
# 26
O_o
# 25
Weird match up...wich will make this very interesting to see.
# 24
hey yall...imma vote on this battle. I hope its gonna be as interesting as everyone says its gonna be. I looked over each charrie and am happy with both. Mr. I is a super hero i have a sort of complex for superheros lol. And Kimi is some sorta catwoman, shes madd cute. Good luck guys. And Smiley i think u do have to wait the last couple days.
# 23
If both fights are posted, do we still have to wait the remaining 5 days?
# 22
I just uploaded everything. ^_^;
# 21
We will see within a week just who will win!
# 20
i am uploaded folks!!! and in the words of jay-z "i will not lose"
# 19
you have a week extension chickie... chilllll
# 18
*hand this fight to Mr. Impossible.
# 17
Well I've tried emailing toast, Posting in the tag board, and PM toast on the messageboard. So I guess I'll had this fight to Mr. Impossible. I tried =[.
# 16
the clock is winding down!
# 15
hope u get u're battle in on time smiley. don't want the Aliance to be known as the default squad. but good luck i just know this'll be a close battle.
# 14
2 get an extension email toast @ toast@entervoid.com.
and then just ask him for the extension
and then just ask him for the extension
# 13
thank you C2, and i have no idea. im still a new guy. ask the boards
# 12
Ok, I'm going to need that extension! How do I get one? o_O?
# 11
Mr.I..... I want some high quality H20, got me?
# 10
do what you have to. i 'm still on schedual
# 9
I've been busy recently and I only have one page half done. I might have to ask for an extension.
# 8
good luck guys. this'll be interesting
# 7
Thank's guys! =]
# 6
yeah smiley i have faith in you even though you are facing "The World's Greatest" and one of my heroes, I still believe in you. And just look at it this way when I get on(IF I EVER GET ON!!!) i have to fight him first too.
# 5
come on!! first thing to win it is believe that you can win..and work for it!!!
# 4
have more faith in yourself!
# 3
lol I know I'm going to lose this fight.
# 2
That's cause you have half of the fight already done!!! lol
# 1
oh boy watch out cuz here i come!!!
Regular Match
Drawing Time:
6 weeks
Ended:
Sep 17th, 2004
Votes Cast:
29
Page Views:
1590
Winner:
mr. impossible
einsam
Colbitzer
@ 3:32 PM Apr 17th
Birthright
Saal, Louise Ambre-Aliona, and Llaana
@ 3:44 PM Apr 16th
Help Needed
Theakon
@ 2:19 PM Apr 16th
The Great Switcheroo
Louise Ambre-Aliona vs. Luniel Gekka
@ 3:26 AM Apr 15th
The Great Switcheroo
Colbitzer vs. Veruca Chance
@ 5:22 PM Apr 14th
| ||
| ||
| ||
| ||
|
536 Guests, 2 Users
[] [Global Moderator]
Most Online Today: 643.
Most Online Ever: 1,184 (Jan 13, 2020, 06:21 PM)
Artist