dumas vs. j.j
Critiques & Comments
Chair
34 comments
# 31
Posted:
Jun 25 2007, 12:37 PM
yes! i love these two, especially when they battle, excellent choice :d
# 30
Posted:
Jun 25 2007, 02:53 AM
Jing and Mickey made some hilarious battles, every single one of them haha.
# 29
Posted:
Jun 23 2007, 09:42 AM
Even to this day, Jho still wants to re-battle Mickey again.
# 28
Posted:
Jun 22 2007, 09:35 PM
Whats a historic battle?
# 27
Posted:
Jun 22 2007, 01:25 PM
OH MY SHIT MY ENTRY SUCKED. Mickey should\'ve won this one!!!!!!!
# 26
Posted:
Jun 22 2007, 01:02 PM
HAHA OH MAN, this was one of my favorite fights ever. I still quote Dumas\' monologue in JJ\'s fight up \'til today.
# 25
My my my, this is a tough one again. Jin, you really know how to pick your opponents eh?
Personally, in terms of art work, both are equally good. They both have great art techniques, style, angles and framing. It's entertaining that both artists protrayed their opponents characters in almost exactly the same way they are were drawn by their respective artists. In other words, Jin's Dumas looks like Dumas' Dumas. (know what I mean?)
Dumas' story is indeed entertaining in a sense the main theme is a simple prank that turns into friendship. Jin's story is also of a similar theme but in a sense, was worded more creativly in terms of script, art work and sequence of events.
Tough decision but I'd tip my hats of to both artists, but Jin, you still da girl man. I'd never thought of putting super glue on someone's eye man!
Grimsg
Personally, in terms of art work, both are equally good. They both have great art techniques, style, angles and framing. It's entertaining that both artists protrayed their opponents characters in almost exactly the same way they are were drawn by their respective artists. In other words, Jin's Dumas looks like Dumas' Dumas. (know what I mean?)
Dumas' story is indeed entertaining in a sense the main theme is a simple prank that turns into friendship. Jin's story is also of a similar theme but in a sense, was worded more creativly in terms of script, art work and sequence of events.
Tough decision but I'd tip my hats of to both artists, but Jin, you still da girl man. I'd never thought of putting super glue on someone's eye man!
Grimsg
# 24
both of these are extremely well done... i'm going with mickey, if for no other reason than it's a bit clearer.
# 23
hahahaaaa. XD
Thanks for the great reads, ladies.
Thanks for the great reads, ladies.
# 22
great job, both of ya xD
# 21
My first vote ever! except for that indigo beyond battle... but anyways....
I thought dumas's side was pretty cool, but the last few pages seemed a little messy and rushed. Awesome job with the colored pages, though.
j.j.'s was funny as heck, and very clever with the character development stuff. The background colors were a little inconsistent, and that bugged me just a bit, but that's probably just me.
great job to the both of you!
I thought dumas's side was pretty cool, but the last few pages seemed a little messy and rushed. Awesome job with the colored pages, though.
j.j.'s was funny as heck, and very clever with the character development stuff. The background colors were a little inconsistent, and that bugged me just a bit, but that's probably just me.
great job to the both of you!
# 20
This is a toughie... seriously you two girls are so alike it's frightning... how do I know you two aren't the same person (checks photo thread) oh... I guess you two are different after all...
Mickey: Great art dude! But I think the randomness wasn't entirely thought out as it should of been, but that's a minor thing if you ask me so don't worry about it.
Jingy thingy: (sorry...) Art is just as good girl! But you managed to entertain me more with your storyline, so that gives you a slight advantage for me.
My vote goes to J.J., but rest ashured that like everybody else, I think this was too close for comfort voting wise. You both make excellent rivals if you ask me (or partners... one or the two). Keep it up or something?
Mickey: Great art dude! But I think the randomness wasn't entirely thought out as it should of been, but that's a minor thing if you ask me so don't worry about it.
Jingy thingy: (sorry...) Art is just as good girl! But you managed to entertain me more with your storyline, so that gives you a slight advantage for me.
My vote goes to J.J., but rest ashured that like everybody else, I think this was too close for comfort voting wise. You both make excellent rivals if you ask me (or partners... one or the two). Keep it up or something?
# 19
KKKKKKEEEEEEEERIST this was an awesome battle!!!
I don't even know what to say....so...
Dumas: KICK ASS!
JJ: KICK ASSIER!!!
^^ Good job ladies, I now have a whole new level in my crush for you both.
I don't even know what to say....so...
Dumas: KICK ASS!
JJ: KICK ASSIER!!!
^^ Good job ladies, I now have a whole new level in my crush for you both.
# 18
This was a tie for me. I was thoroughly undecided. Cuz they both were so hott. kbye.
# 17
Oh man, I had such a hard time voting on this one XDD The both of you are awesome! Hilarious storylines. Good luck to you both!
# 16
OMG I WANT TO HAVE A MAD THREESOME WITH YOU TWO NOW
*ahem*
Mickey, your art is way groovy and dynamic as usual. There's so much going on in every page, this entry was definitely not a chore visually. The dialouge was funny, so was seeing J.J. as a porn store clerk. Dumas' odd, bi-polar mood swings are always fun to watch.
Jingu, you know I love you and your orgasmic art. Super gay Orgon cameo rocked the house. My only complaint is that hot damn, where were the crazy border goodies I saw in your intro pages? I know they're probably a bitch to come up with, but really, you're so good at that and they add alot more character to your work.
I demand a rematch and soon. I need my fix.
*ahem*
Mickey, your art is way groovy and dynamic as usual. There's so much going on in every page, this entry was definitely not a chore visually. The dialouge was funny, so was seeing J.J. as a porn store clerk. Dumas' odd, bi-polar mood swings are always fun to watch.
Jingu, you know I love you and your orgasmic art. Super gay Orgon cameo rocked the house. My only complaint is that hot damn, where were the crazy border goodies I saw in your intro pages? I know they're probably a bitch to come up with, but really, you're so good at that and they add alot more character to your work.
I demand a rematch and soon. I need my fix.
# 15
this was DAMN ENTRETAINING, and I shall read it again BOTH.
you girls make it so hard to decide,
MIGUELA: nicely drawn, prety clean and wicked colors on some panels.
Jingu: you made me laugh.
THIS BATTLE MADE IT TO MY ALL TIME FAVORITE LIST.
good job you two.
you girls make it so hard to decide,
MIGUELA: nicely drawn, prety clean and wicked colors on some panels.
Jingu: you made me laugh.
THIS BATTLE MADE IT TO MY ALL TIME FAVORITE LIST.
good job you two.
# 14
while i LOVE dumas's style, and I love jj's humor.....
i just barely sway to JJ's vote...barely... it's not cause of the colors really, but rather....... super glue on his third eye... omg lol
i just barely sway to JJ's vote...barely... it's not cause of the colors really, but rather....... super glue on his third eye... omg lol
# 13
omfg mickey be my internet girlfriend plzkthx
no seriously, I love this. we should rematch sometime so I can make better dumas. this IS ROCKING.
no seriously, I love this. we should rematch sometime so I can make better dumas. this IS ROCKING.
# 12
so sorry for the sucky story and coloring job. I'll do better next time, perhaps a rematch!
# 11
both artists have requested an extension so match is pushed forward for jingui and miCkey
# 10
mikey has an extension
# 9
Sweet Jello Biafra on a stick, this is going to be epic.
# 8
looking foward to this one... bet its gonna be hilarious! good luck!
# 7
fucking sweet
# 6
OMFG.
# 5
Ohh snap, this is gonna be one hell of a match.
# 4
a fight im def looking for, good luck to you both
# 3
haha this was bound to happen it was destiny!
# 2
Total Bossness! This is going to be pretty cool ^_~
# 1
OH SNAP!
Regular Match
Drawing Time:
4 weeks
Ended:
Jan 23rd, 2005
Votes Cast:
43
Page Views:
1674
Winner:
jho
99 Problems and a Cat
Croi Desai vs. HR99
@ 12:30 AM Apr 23rd
einsam
Colbitzer
@ 3:32 PM Apr 17th
Birthright
Saal, Louise Ambre-Aliona, and Llaana
@ 3:44 PM Apr 16th
Help Needed
Theakon
@ 2:19 PM Apr 16th
The Great Switcheroo
Louise Ambre-Aliona vs. Luniel Gekka
@ 3:26 AM Apr 15th
| ||
| ||
| ||
| ||
|
247 Guests, 0 Users
Most Online Today: 430.
Most Online Ever: 1,184 (Jan 13, 2020, 06:21 PM)